Equivalence relations on ecosystems

In abstract terms, ecosystem ecology is about determining when two ecosystems, superficially different, are alike in some deeper way. An external observer can choose any ecosystem property as being important. In contrast, two ecosystems are equivalent from the point of view of the organisms they contain if and only if for each species, the proportional population growth rate does not differ between the ecosystems. Comparative studies of ecosystems should therefore focus on patterns in proportional population growth rates, rather than patterns in other properties such as relative abundances. Popular activities such as measuring dissimilarity, and representing dissimilarity via ordination, can then be done from the point of view of the organisms in ecosystems. Summarizing the state of an ecosystem under this approach remains challenging. In general, the dynamics on equivalence classes of ecosystems defined in this way are structurally different from the dynamics of ecosystems as seen by an external observer. This may limit the extent to which natural selection can act on ecosystem structure.